The tooth fairy going rate varies by region across the US. Select your region and tooth type to see the average payment based on 2025 Delta Dental Original Tooth Fairy Poll data, with milestone notes.
Check the Going Rate
Average by Region — 2025 Reference
| Region | Average | Typical Range |
|---|---|---|
| Northeast | $7.25 | $4–$12 |
| West | $7.01 | $4–$12 |
| Midwest | $5.83 | $2–$10 |
| South | $5.52 | $2–$10 |
How to Set a Tooth Fairy Rate Your Family Will Love
The tooth fairy going rate isn't fixed — it's whatever creates magic in your home. But having a reference point helps you decide what feels right without going wildly above or below local norms (which can cause awkward conversations when your child compares notes with friends).
Make the First Tooth Special
Most families give a premium for the first tooth — typically 2–3x the standard rate. The first tooth loss is a developmental milestone that feels enormous to a 5- or 6-year-old. A special amount, a note from the tooth fairy, or a small keepsake box all make the memory more vivid.
Consistency Matters
Whatever rate you pick, try to be consistent across teeth (with the exception of special milestones like the first tooth or first molar). Nothing deflates the magic faster than one tooth getting $5 and the next getting $2. Consider setting a standard amount and sticking to it.
Using the Tooth Fairy as a Financial Teaching Moment
Some parents have the tooth fairy leave a mix of denominations (quarters, dollar bills) to make counting and saving feel tangible. Others suggest saving part of the tooth fairy money toward a bigger goal. A small savings jar in a child's room makes the connection between saving and having more very concrete.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is this tooth fairy reference free?
Yes, completely free with no signup required.
What is the average tooth fairy payment in 2025?
According to the Delta Dental Tooth Fairy Poll, the national average was approximately $6.23 per tooth in 2023 (the most recent data available). This represents a significant increase from earlier years and varies considerably by region.
Should the first tooth get more money?
Many families give a premium for the first tooth — often 2–3x the usual amount. The first tooth is a memorable milestone, and a special payment makes it feel more significant. Some families also give a special gift (a small toy or jewelry box) for the first tooth.
What if I can't afford $5–$6 per tooth?
The tooth fairy doesn't have a fixed rate — any amount that feels special to your child is appropriate. Some families give coins, which feel substantial to young children even if the dollar amount is small. Others give $1 per tooth consistently. The ritual and magic matter more than the dollar amount.
Do different teeth get different amounts?
Many parents give the first molar a higher rate (similar to the first tooth), since molars are harder to lose and more significant developmentally. Front teeth (incisors) that are highly visible often get standard rates, while back teeth may get slightly less.